Primary Menu

Dave Portnoy, creator of Barstool Sports and famed pizza reviewer, has been to a few pizza shops in Southwest Florida in the last year or so.

His online pizza reviews called ‘One Bite Pizza Reviews‘ have added to his Barstool fame.  He rates pizzas from around the US on a scale of one to 10. Part of his criteria is how much grease it has or “the flop”, and he’s always looking for a well-done “undercarriage.” His favorite style is Neapolitan with no toppings, only cheese. His ratings are brutally honest and don’t always make for the happiest local owners.  If you’re in the 7 range, consider yourself to have a good slice.

Each of his reviews is recorded by his pal Frankie or Spider, or another Barstool friend, and posted on his YouTube channel.

We’ve found 4 locations here in Southwest Florida and listed them below, along with Dave’s rating and video review.

Check out the list:

  • Grandpa's Pizza - Bonita Springs

    Dave’s Rating – 7.8

  • Lowbrow Pizza & Beer - Naples

    Dave’s Rating – 7.1

  • Industry Pizza & Slice Shop - Naples

    Dave’s Rating – 7.7

  • Taglio Cucina & Pizzeria Romana - Port Charlotte

    Dave’s Rating – 7.7

  • Costco Pizza

    Dave’s Rating – 1.9

  • Panera Pizza

    Dave’s Rating – 6.1

  • Chuck E. Cheese Pizza

    Dave’s Rating – 6

  • Lunchables Pizza

    Dave’s Rating – 1.1

  • DiGiorno Pizza

    Dave’s Rating – 2.8

  • Bagel Bites

    Dave’s Rating – 6.9